How to price a lifetime plan next to a subscription.
Every subscription app eventually gets the review that says “I’d happily pay once, just let me buy it.” Adding a lifetime option looks like free money: a third button on the paywall for the people who hate subscriptions. It isn’t a third price, though. A lifetime plan is a bet on how long a subscriber would have stayed, settled in cash on day one, and most apps that offer one never do the arithmetic on that bet. Here’s how to do it.
Start from what a subscriber is worth
The number a lifetime price has to beat is the total a subscriber would have paid you if they had stayed on the annual plan. If a fraction r of annual subscribers renew each year, the expected number of payments is 1 + r + r² + …, which sums to 1 ÷ (1 − r). So:
Worked through with an illustrative $40 annual plan: at a 40% renewal rate a subscriber pays an expected 1.67 times, so the break-even lifetime price is about $67. At 60% it’s 2.5 payments, or $100. At 75% it’s four payments, or $160. The renewal rate moves the answer more than anything else, so use your own figure from the subscription retention reports in App Store Connect or Play Console, not a benchmark and not a guess.
Two refinements make the formula more honest. Renewal rates usually improve after the first year, because the people who were going to leave mostly left at the first renewal, so a single blended rate understates what a second-year subscriber is worth. And money in five years is worth less to you than money today, which pulls the number back down a little. For an indie app, neither changes the order of magnitude; the renewal rate does.
The people who buy it aren’t average
The formula gives you the value of an average subscriber, and the average subscriber is not who clicks the lifetime button. Someone paying several years up front expects to use the app for several years. That’s your most loyal cohort choosing to prepay at a discount, which means every lifetime sale to a person who would have subscribed anyway trades their full long-term value for a single payment.
The other buyer is the one the reviews are about: someone who would never have subscribed at any price. That sale is new money. A lifetime plan earns its place when the second group is big enough to outweigh the discount you give the first. You can’t see that split directly, but you can watch for its shadow: if annual sales drop by roughly as many as lifetime sales arrive, you’re mostly converting subscribers into one-time buyers.
That’s why the break-even price is a floor, not a target. Price toward the value of the subscribers who stay past the first renewal, because they’re the ones most likely to switch.
The costs that never stop
A lifetime buyer pays once and keeps costing you for as long as the app exists: support email, sync storage, server time, and, most of all, any AI feature billed per call. We wrote about how your heaviest user sets the price of an AI feature; on a lifetime plan, that heaviest user has prepaid for a fixed amount and can run up costs indefinitely.
If a feature has a real marginal cost per use, keep it out of the lifetime unlock. Sell lifetime access to the app itself, and meter the expensive part separately with credits or a small add-on subscription. If the metered feature is the app, don’t offer lifetime at all. A local-only utility with no server bill is the natural fit; a product built on an AI API usually isn’t.
The store’s cut isn’t the same on both
Under Apple’s standard terms, auto-renewable subscriptions carry a 30% commission during a subscriber’s first year of paid service and 15% after that. A one-time purchase never reaches the second year; it stays at the full rate. So for a developer on standard terms, a subscriber who stays three years keeps you 85% of years two and three, while the lifetime buyer kept you 70% of everything. If you’re enrolled in the App Store Small Business Program, the rate is 15% on both and the difference disappears.
Google restructured its Play service fees in 2026, with different rates for new and existing installs in some regions. Rather than trust a number from a blog post, including this one, look up the current rate for one-time products and subscriptions in your Play Console before you run the comparison.
One more Apple setting to decide before launch: Family Sharing. If you turn it on for the lifetime purchase, everyone in the buyer’s family group gets it, and Apple’s documentation is explicit that once Family Sharing is on for an in-app purchase, you can’t turn it off. Price with that in mind, or leave it off.
Cash now is not growth
A lifetime sale lands as one large payment, which feels wonderful in the month it happens and is invisible in every month after. It’s the extreme version of the problem in our post on annual plans as loans: you’ve been paid for service you haven’t delivered yet. A launch week with a burst of lifetime purchases can read like traction while it quietly removes your keenest users from next year’s recurring revenue. Track lifetime revenue on its own line, and judge growth on recurring revenue alone.
Where it goes on the paywall
There are three common placements, and each sends a different message.
Always visible, as the third option. It works as an anchor: next to a lifetime price, the annual plan looks reasonable. The risk is that it becomes the obvious choice for exactly the loyal users you’d rather keep subscribed, so price it well clear of the annual plan. If lifetime costs less than about two years of annual, anyone who expects to stay two years should pick it, and the math above says you’ve probably underpriced it.
Shown only to people who decline. Offer it to someone who has dismissed the subscription paywall a few times, or who is about to cancel. This targets the subscription-averse buyer directly and keeps lifetime away from people happy to subscribe.
Time-boxed. A lifetime price for a launch or an anniversary, then gone. It raises cash and rewards early supporters without becoming a permanent alternative to the subscription. Be careful with this if you ever plan to bring it back cheaper: people who paid the launch price remember.
Whatever you choose, raising the lifetime price later is easy and reads as normal. Cutting it tells everyone who already paid that they overpaid.
The implementation details that bite
On Apple, make the lifetime option a non-consumable in-app purchase, so it restores on a new device and your entitlement check can treat it the same as an active subscription. On Google Play it’s a one-time product, and the purchase must be acknowledged within three days or Google refunds it automatically, which is an easy way to lose lifetime sales to a missed server call.
Then handle the subscriber who upgrades. Buying lifetime doesn’t cancel an existing subscription. On Google Play your server can cancel it through the Play Developer API. On iOS only the user can, so after the purchase, tell them plainly and open the system’s manage-subscriptions sheet for them. A customer billed for a subscription after paying for lifetime will ask for a refund, and they’ll be right to.
If you’re still deciding how people meet the paywall in the first place, start with hard paywall versus freemium. Apple’s rules on sharing are in its Family Sharing help page.