Is a Black Friday sale worth running in your app?
Black Friday lands on November 27 this year, with Cyber Monday on the 30th. Inboxes fill with “50% off” and plenty of indie developers wonder whether their app should join in. The honest answer depends on two things the banner hides: who actually takes the deal, and which store setting you use to give it. One of the obvious settings on the App Store can’t be undone.
Start with who the discount is for
A sale only pays for itself if it brings in people who wouldn’t have bought otherwise. Everyone who was going to buy that week anyway now pays less. The arithmetic is unforgiving. Say you normally sell 100 annual plans at $40 in the last week of November, which is $4,000. At 40% off the plan costs $24, and you need about 167 sales just to make the same $4,000. The sale has to find 67 extra buyers before it earns a cent more than doing nothing.
Subscriptions soften that, as long as the discount only covers the first period. Next November the plan renews at $40, so the real cost is this year’s difference on the people who would have paid full price. That only holds if the sale cohort renews as well as your usual subscribers. People who came for a deal are the ones most likely to leave when the deal ends. Tag the sale purchases so you can compare their renewal rate a year from now. That number tells you whether to do this again.
Also be realistic about reach. A sale doesn’t create visitors. It mostly reaches people who already know you: your free users, your mailing list, your followers. It works best for an app with a pool of people who installed it, used it, hit the paywall and hesitated. The sale gives them a deadline. If you don’t have that pool, a discount just lowers the price for the few strangers who would have bought anyway.
The setting that cuts your price for good
The obvious move on Apple is to open your subscription’s pricing in App Store Connect, lower it for the weekend and put it back on Tuesday. Apple’s help page on subscription pricing is explicit about what happens. When you decrease the price, existing subscriptions “will automatically renew at the lower price.” You don’t have the option to keep the higher price for existing subscribers. And once the decrease takes effect, “it can’t be reversed.”
So the weekend sale reaches far beyond the weekend. Every subscriber you already have, including the ones who were happily paying full price, renews at the sale price from then on. Putting it back is a price increase on all of them. You either keep the current, lower price for existing subscribers, which makes the discount permanent for your most loyal customers, or you move them up and trigger Apple’s increase notices or consent requests. Our post on raising prices on current subscribers covers what that costs. Apple also lets you schedule only one future price change at a time per storefront, so you can’t queue the drop and the restore together.
Google Play behaves differently but has its own trap. Changing a base plan’s price applies straight away to new purchases, and existing subscribers move into a legacy price cohort at what they were already paying. A decrease looks harmless. The trouble comes when you raise it back: everyone who subscribed during the sale becomes a legacy cohort at the sale price, and moving them up later is an opt-in increase that cancels anyone who doesn’t accept.
What to use instead on Apple
For subscriptions, use an introductory offer. It has a start date and an end date you choose, and it ends on its own. There are three types: free trial, pay as you go and pay up front. For Black Friday, pay up front on the annual plan is the cleanest: the first year at $24, then $40 a year after that. Your list price never moves, so nobody already subscribed is affected.
Read two lines in Apple’s help before you create it. Introductory offers can’t be edited once created. And a new offer with overlapping dates overwrites the existing one. If you run a standing free trial, the sale offer replaces it for those dates, so put a reminder in your calendar for Tuesday, December 1 to check that your normal trial is back.
The bigger limit is eligibility. Each person can redeem one introductory offer per subscription group, ever. Anyone who already took your free trial and didn’t convert won’t see the Black Friday price. That is often exactly the group you most wanted to reach. For them, Apple’s promotional offers and offer codes are the tools. We covered how those work, and who can see each, in what the stores let you offer someone who cancelled.
For a paid app or a one-time purchase such as a lifetime unlock, the right tool is a temporary price change. You pick the start and end dates when you schedule it, and Apple’s help confirms that price changes “can have definite start and end dates.” This one does return to the old price on its own.
What to use instead on Google Play
Paid apps get a dedicated sales feature, with rules worth knowing before Friday. Sales work only for paid apps, not for subscriptions or in-app products. The discount must be at least 10% in every affected country, a sale lasts from one to fourteen days, the app must already be published, and the earliest start date is the next day. There must also be 30 days between the end of one sale and the start of the next, so a Black Friday sale rules out another one until the end of December.
For subscriptions, create an offer on the base plan with new customer acquisition eligibility, which Google checks for you. The help page describes offers as active or inactive, and you toggle between them, so plan for someone to switch it off on Tuesday. One-time products have had their own purchase options and offers since 2025, so a lifetime unlock can carry a discount without changing its base price either.
There is a catch that has nothing to do with the console. On Play, your app chooses which offer to launch in the billing flow. If your purchase code always picks the base plan, a new offer never appears, however you configure it. On Apple an introductory offer applies to eligible buyers automatically, but a paywall that hard-codes “$39.99 a year” will still show the wrong price. Either fix needs a build, and a build needs review. If your paywall can’t already show an offer price from the store, the update has to go out this week.
Tell people where they already are
The sale is only as good as the number of people who hear about it. Put the offer on the paywall with its real end date, and send it to your mailing list on Thursday or Friday morning. Don’t fake urgency with a countdown that restarts every time someone opens the app.
On the App Store, the 170-character promotional text is the right place for a sale line. It sits above your description and changes without a review. Screenshots are the wrong place, because on Apple they only change with a new version. A “Black Friday” frame means one review to put it up and another to take it down, and if the second one is slow, you’re advertising an expired deal into December.
If the answer is no, that’s a fine answer. Plenty of apps make more by keeping one honest price all year than by teaching their users to wait for November.